THE SECRET TO KATIE’S COOKIES

I can’t believe November is almost here and along with it, another Anchor at Home! I look forward to hosting a watch party and am already thinking about whom I will invite and what I will serve my guests.

Besides my tried-and-true appetizer platter/charcuterie board which I shared in September, I also have a dessert I am known for among my family and friends. I like to include it in my array of snacks and treats. For as long as I can remember, I’ve been known for my chocolate chip cookies, better known as “Katie’s Cookies”.

Since I was a young girl, I have had an obsession with this favorite treat. It all started when I would sneak spoonfuls of chocolate chip cookie dough from the mixing bowl while my older sisters were baking. I would wait for just the right moment when they weren’t looking and dip my spoon into the creamy dough and make a fast dash out of the kitchen.

My KitchenAid mixer creaming the dough

As I grew older and was able to make them myself, I was able to learn the secrets of making the perfect chocolate chip cookie. I LOVE cookie dough, and I found myself longing for the weekend so I could make cookie dough as a reward and treat for finishing a week of work. In college during my summers off from the University of Washington, I worked at a summer camp as a counselor and my camp name was NESTLE after my favorite cookie ingredient. This name and the chocolate chip cookies I brought weekly to camp were a hit among the campers!

I loved chocolate chip cookie dough and the baked cookies SO much I perfected my recipe to be a “lighter” version so I could eat twice as many 😉 (jump to the recipe where I share my secrets below!).

I made these cookies for every event and for every Young Life Campaigners group I led over the years. Often, I would just plop a big bowl of cookie dough and some spoons on the counter and it was the treat everyone longed for and devoured. I kept the baked cookies in my freezer and would find that over the years when Young Life kids would come into our home, they made a beeline for the freezer! I even dreamed of having a “Katie’s Cookies” business.

As time went on I shared, the “true confessions of Katie” and called myself a cookie dough addict and wondered if any one else craved this sugary delight as much as I did! I remember the first time I saw cookie dough ice cream and cookie dough bites in my local grocery store and was relieved to find I wasn’t the only one. Can any of you relate?!

For many years I have been asked for my special chocolate chip cookie recipe, and I always give it to whoever asks. There is just one slight problem in that some just can’t seem to make them turn out exactly like my “Katie’s Cookies” so I began sharing my methods and would hold cookie classes in my kitchen.

I would always start with my most prized possession — the KitchenAid mixer my parents gave me 34 years ago as a wedding gift. Each participant was required to bring their own mixer and ingredients, and we would set up, ready for our cookie baking adventure. Step by step, I would share how to make my chocolate chip cookies.

Baking together in person was the key to a successful cookie!

Freshly baked “Katie’s Cookies”

So for those who would like to make a very delicious cookie, I am providing the secrets and steps to my “Katie’s cookies” below, both with the recipe and a video bake-along!

Confession: I’ve always used the Nestle Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe found on the back of the chocolate chip bag (albeit with a few modifications). The steps and recipe below are for a double batch. I find a KitchenAid works best but any mixer will do.

Katie's Cookies

The Anchor's Founder & Director shares her "famous" chocolate-chip cookie recipe adapted from the back of the Nestle Chocolate Chip bag.
Course: Dessert
Keyword: cookies

Equipment

  • KitchenAid mixer (or other mixer)
  • Oven

Ingredients

  • 4 eggs
  • cups sugar
  • cups brown sugar
  • ½ cup Crisco
  • ¼ cup butter
  • 3 tsp vanilla extract (one extra than the original recipe)
  • 2 tsp baking soda
  • ½ tsp salt
  • cups flour
  • 3 cups Nestle chocolate chips semi-sweet, 1½ bags

Instructions

  • Preheat the oven to 375 degrees.
  • Cream together on high: eggs, sugar, brown sugar, Crisco, butter, and vanilla extract. Cream until the consistency is smooth and creamy. (Note: I add one extra teaspoon of vanilla which is one more than the original recipe requires.)
    4 eggs, 1½ cups sugar, 1½ cups brown sugar, ½ cup Crisco, ¼ cup butter, 3 tsp vanilla extract
  • Add the baking soda, salt, flour and chocolate chips and mix to combine.
    2 tsp baking soda, ½ tsp salt, 3½ cups flour, 3 cups Nestle chocolate chips
  • Drop by the spoonful onto cookie sheets.
  • Bake for 4 minutes.
  • Rotate the cookie sheets and bake for an additional 4 minutes.
  • Use a spatula to transfer the cookies onto parchment paper or a paper towel to cool.
  • After the cookies have cooled, you can place them carefully into a Ziplog bag and freeze to store or serve warm on a plate and enjoy!

Video

Ready for my watch party — ENJOY!

I am excited for our November Anchor at Home on Thursday, November 4th. I hope and pray you’ll be able to gather together with friends and family and be encouraged and anchored in faith and friendship AND enjoy a delicious cookie!

Feel free to post YOUR cookies on our Facebook and Instagram. I would LOVE to see them!

With hope and light,

Catch up on last week’s journal entry!

Anchor Moment with Elizabeth Kreiselmaier

Read Now
Follow us on facebook
Follow us on Instagram